Reflections on Human Resource Management

Posted by: Rudra Pandey

The most valuable asset of a company is human resource. It is all about employees in the company and every employee matters. Someone who does not matter should not be in the company. Hiring and keeping great ones, converting even mediocre ones to great ones, and firing those who do not matter help a company build a great team. A company which sticks to the mantra that every employee matters and takes care of each of them will prosper and grow year after year and continually beating competitors. Companies that ignore the rank and files thinking that only super-stars and senior managers matter will gradually lose market share and will start going downhill rapidly. This raises the important question about who comes, who stays and who should go. Very simple – keep the ones with a “winning” attitude and let losers go.

Recruiting is always the first challenge. A company cannot build a great team by just hiring a bunch of superstars from a common background. The hallmark of a great team is its diversity and a proper mixture of talents. For example, neither can you expect a bunch of novel prize winners to build a successful organization, nor a group of MIT engineers can translate their concept into reality. People from different social, ethnic, geographical and educational backgrounds bring different spirits and add different values to a team. When people from varied backgrounds argue with each other and reach a common conclusion that they all agree on, we are very likely to get a balanced and sustainable solution to a problem or an issue. It is also less likely that people from different backgrounds may unite with each other for a wrong reason than people from the same background. Furthermore, sometimes some very smart people try to overcomplicate simple stuff because they are used to addressing only complex issues. Average people try to find simple solutions to any kind of problem. A real world problem may have a simple or a complex solution – we never know. When a proper combination of talents work jointly to solve a problem, by and large we are likely to find the best possible solution. Mixing people of different talent levels and backgrounds creates debates and argument which is the spirit of a good organization.

Many companies simply hire people from great schools and believe that the rest will be taken care of by itself. Hiring all “A” graders does not get us there. When it comes to performance at work, attitude matters more than academic performance and intelligence. An average person can become a great contributor if they have a “can do” and “will do” attitude, positive energy and the willingness to accept that learning is a life-long process. Getting straight “A”s in school does not guarantee that they will be an equally excellent player in the workplace. However, many managers love brand names and graduates from great schools are embraced with open arms without testing the key attribute required of someone to become a great worker. A “winning” attitude – the key attribute – should be the first screening. If a person passes the first screening, then they should be tested on other attributes such as past experience, school performance and subject matter expertise. The most difficult task in the recruitment process is recognizing a winner.

Who is a winner? A winner speaks the truth and never boasts or exaggerates past accomplishments. A winner can put their strengths and weaknesses in simple words without any confusion. The ability to explain career goals in clear terms is an essential quality that all winners possess. Winners have a clear idea of what they want to achieve in the next 3-4 years and beyond. They have a dream, a goal and a strong desire to win. A winner is competitive, but always goes above and beyond expectations to appreciate others – this is what I call “positive energy”. Actions speak louder than words – a winner always leads by example and never tries to lecture others unnecessarily. A winning worker makes their manager proud and they do not need to ask for anything – raises and promotions follow them. In addition, a winner knows how to lead a conversation and find a topic to discuss that matches given circumstances. If you are having one-on-one meeting with a winner, you should not be worrying about what to talk about next. A winner will find something to engage you in a positive and constructive way. Some winners become the darlings of all because of their great sense of humor. Confidence, but never over-confidence, is something fundamental that every winner has.

Who is a loser? A confused, unhappy and stiff person is likely to be a loser. Some people are never satisfied and they keep on asking for more than what they deserve. When they do so, they create an environment where people start setting unrealistic demands. In addition, they cannot stay without passing negative comments to anything they come across. These kinds of people not only lose, but also may bring the whole team down. They are fickle minded depicting a lack of clarity and interpretable vision. They tend to be jealous and over-ambitious to add to their unhappiness. These kind of people may win (or may have won in the past) by chance, but I do not call them winners. A winner wins for the team. Winning for oneself is not winning – that is cheating. Losers lack confidence, but, in contrast, end up portraying themselves as over-confident when they try to hide their lack of confidence. This makes them look arrogant and confused.

Who can hire a winner? It is very unlikely that losers will recognize winners. Even if they do, they are afraid of being defeated / challenged and by and large avoid hiring winners. If a company has clumsy, narrow minded, unhappy, negative and jealous managers, are most likely to hire similar people. Winning culture should, therefore, start from the top. If an organization has a CEO with a losing attitude, the company will have an extremely tough road ahead and things will start falling apart in no time. I would say that a team led by a loser can never win.

To err is human. We make mistakes. Sometimes we end up hiring despite our best intentions. We should not give up easily. We should first try to convert such a person to a winner. Many people change for the good when they are coached and motivated towards a good common cause. But some people just do not change no matter what. Their unwillingness to change for the good becomes poisonous for the team. If that happens, the manger should find a way to get rid of such people. I am sure there are places out there where those people will fit. As a winner, we need to have respect for every person in the earth. We do a favor by letting people know their weaknesses and allowing them to seek career opportunities that is best suited for them. The world is big and there is a place for everyone. A small company should promote diversity, but should not let one or two person destroy the company culture in the name of diversity.

Reflections on Human Resource Management was last modified: September 12th, 2013 by Rudra Pandey

Blog Comments

  1. HR Management


    Society theory assumes that employees and employers have different goals, act in a self-interested manner, and are willing to assume varying degrees of risk. In this paper, we argue that cultural differences may attenuate those assumptions and thereby temper agency theory predictions.

  2. HR Consulting

    Nice posting

    Finally, your own experience of work is excellent material for reflection and can provide insightful information and understanding on HRM theory

    Thanks for…

  3. lpk

    When Hirirng, the employer actually does not know who is being hired. The hired person will encompass all good qualities as expected or will turn out as a rouge? can be answered only after a few days,weeks, and months. HRM is seen to be implemented effectively by only some organizations in Nepal, else, it has been a total failure including the policy of Government.

  4. dovan

    “let’s grow together!!”

    When employees have confidence that their company cares for it’s employees growth along with it’s own , they get very motivated and have care and concern for their work and company.

    This brings greater efficiency and productivity.

    D2 seems one of those that have very well realised and followed this fact.

  5. heretic

    People who run most of the organizations in Nepal still haven’t let a simple concept sink through: “To prosper and grow, keep the people who work for you happy.”

    I feel extremely fortunate to be working in one of the very few organizations that actually follows this principle.

  6. Supriya

    Accomplishments whether big or small marks a winner.Winners do have a winning attitude, no doubt. But a person with a winning attitude is still a loser if he/she does not walk that extra mile to achieve his/her dream.In fact,a person having a dream and not working towards achieveing it is even a bigger loser.
    Every accomplishment begins with a dream. And dreams do come true if we only work hard enough!

  7. Vishnu Kshettri

    Rudra very well said. It is a description of a great teacher who is always keen to learn and seek his mistake if he finds his pupil failed. Subservience is seed of suffering in this world. Looking forward to read more in due course.

  8. dovan

    Reading this post , I remembered a story of russian nesting dolls(set of dolls of decreasing sizes placed one inside another).

    In a company, if a person hires another person bigger and better than himself,the company eventually grows into a company of giants.

    But if a person ,due to his insecurities hires a person smaller and weaker than himself, the company ends as a company of dwarfs.

Post Your Comments:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *